Monday , October 15 2018
Home / Bank of International Settlement / The perils of approximating fixed-horizon inflation forecasts with fixed-event forecasts

The perils of approximating fixed-horizon inflation forecasts with fixed-event forecasts

Summary:
By James Yetman Summary Focus Inflation forecasts are either "fixed event" (eg forecasts made each month for inflation in 2017) or "fixed horizon" (eg forecasts made each month for inflation over the coming 12 months). Fixed-event forecasts are preferable for some purposes, and fixed-horizon forecasts for others. However, fixed-event forecasts are generally more readily available than fixed-horizon ones. A common practice is therefore to convert fixed-event forecasts to fixed-horizon ones. We examine the effect of this conversion on the properties of the forecasts. Contribution We focus on US forecast data that we can use to produce both actual and approximate fixed-horizon inflation forecasts with a 12-month horizon. We

Topics:
International Settlement considers the following as important:

This could be interesting, too:

Jp Koning writes Bitcoin and the bubble theory of money

New York Fed writes Leverage Rule Arbitrage

David McKenzie writes Weekly links October 12: should you decide on ethics by polling, beware the uneven treatment probabilities, roads are good, and more…

International Settlement writes Disentangling the supply and demand factors of household credit in Malaysia: evidence from the credit register

Summary

Focus

Inflation forecasts are either "fixed event" (eg forecasts made each month for inflation in 2017) or "fixed horizon" (eg forecasts made each month for inflation over the coming 12 months). Fixed-event forecasts are preferable for some purposes, and fixed-horizon forecasts for others. However, fixed-event forecasts are generally more readily available than fixed-horizon ones. A common practice is therefore to convert fixed-event forecasts to fixed-horizon ones. We examine the effect of this conversion on the properties of the forecasts.

Contribution

We focus on US forecast data that we can use to produce both actual and approximate fixed-horizon inflation forecasts with a 12-month horizon. We then compare the properties of the two. We find that there are quantitatively important differences between them. We also propose a partial fix for the conversion rule to improve the performance of the approximation.

Findings

We show that the approximation results in significant errors compared with the actual forecasts, equal to about 10% of the inflation rate. This error is more severe during recessions. In addition, measures of how much forecasters tend to disagree with each other, and how persistent forecasts are, may be misleading when we look at approximate forecasts instead of actual ones. We propose an improvement to the approximation, based on the idea that longer-horizon forecasts are more heavily "anchored" to a fixed number while shorter-horizon forecasts more strongly reflect recent inflation. In practical terms, the improvement means that we put a higher weight on longer-horizon forecasts, and a smaller weight on shorter-horizon forecasts, than the standard conversion rule suggests.

 

Abstract

A common practice in studies using inflation forecasts is to approximate fixed-horizon forecasts with fixed-event ones. Here we show that this may be problematic. In a panel of US inflation forecast data that allows us to compare the two, the approximation results in a mean absolute approximation error of around 0.2-0.3 percentage points (around 10% of the level of inflation), and statistically significant differences in both the variances and persistence of the approximate inflation forecasts relative to the actual forecasts. To reduce these problems, we propose an adjustment to the approximation, consistent with a model where longer-horizon forecasts are more heavily "anchored", while shorter-horizon forecasts more closely reflect current inflation levels.

JEL classification: C43, E31

Keywords: fixed-event forecasts, fixed-horizon forecasts, inflation expectations

International Settlement
The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) is an international company limited by shares owned by central banks which "fosters international monetary and financial cooperation and serves as a bank for central banks". The BIS carries out its work through subcommittees, the secretariats it hosts and through an annual general meeting of all member banks. It also provides banking services, but only to central banks and other international organizations. It is based in Basel, Switzerland, with representative offices in Hong Kong and Mexico City.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *